Pines Of Sarasota
1501 N Orange Ave, Sarasota
5/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 4
Nursing home · 171 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Federal record · CMS Care Compare · Processed JUN 1 2026
Highest-rated nursing homes in Sarasota, FL
10 facilities match — of 23 total nursing homes in Sarasota.
Hawthorne Center For Rehab & Healing Of Sarasota
5381 Desoto Road, Sarasota
5/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 4
$9K in fines · 1 fine
Nursing home · 120 certified beds · For-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Sarasota Memorial Nursing & Rehabilitation Center
5640 Rand Blvd, Sarasota
5/5CMS overallStaff 5·Health 4
Nursing home · 120 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Glenridge On Palmer Ranch Inc.
7333 Scotland Way, Sarasota
5/5CMS overallStaff 5·Health 5
Nursing home · 61 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Sunnyside Nursing Home
5201 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota
5/5CMS overallStaff 5·Health 4
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Plymouth Harbor Incorporated
700 John Ringling Blvd, Sarasota
5/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 4
Nursing home · 56 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center
1959 N Honore Ave, Sarasota
5/5CMS overallStaff 5·Health 5
Nursing home · 45 certified beds · For-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Life Care Center Of Sarasota
8104 Tuttle Ave, Sarasota
4/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 3
$19K in fines · 2 fines
Nursing home · 120 certified beds · For-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Sarasota Point Rehabilitation Center
2600 Courtland Street, Sarasota
4/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 3
Nursing home · 120 certified beds · For-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Inn At Sarasota Bay Club
1303 North Tamiami Trail, Sarasota
4/5CMS overallStaff 5·Health 3
Nursing home · 44 certified beds · For-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026