CareWitness
Federal record · CMS Chain Performance Measures · Snapshot JUN 8 2026
CareWitnessSenior CareHurlbut Care

Nursing-home chain

Hurlbut Care

We list 13 facilities in New York, with CMS Care Compare ratings, ownership disclosures, and inspection histories on each.

Facilities listed
13
1 state
Chain-wide footprint
13
1 state (CMS-wide)
Avg overall rating
3.8 / 5
CMS chain-wide
Total fines
$947,011
7 fines
100% for-profit1 on Special Focus Facility list

Facilities by state

New York

13 facilities in New York

Avon Nursing Home L L C

215 Clinton Street, Avon

4/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 4
$33K in fines · 1 fine

Nursing home · 40 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Maple City Rehabilitation And Nursing Center

434 Monroe Avenue, Hornell

1/5CMS overallStaff 2·Health 1
$62K in fines · 1 fine

Nursing home · 114 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Conesus Lake Nursing Home, Llc

6131 Big Tree Road, Livonia

4/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 4

Nursing home · 48 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Newark Manor Nursing Home Inc

222 West Pearl Street, Newark

4/5CMS overallStaff 2·Health 4

Nursing home · 60 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Penfield Place

1700 Penfield Road, Penfield

5/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 5

Nursing home · 48 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Hamilton Manor Nursing Home

1172 Long Pond Road, Rochester

5/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 5

Nursing home · 40 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Latta Road Nursing Home East

2102 Latta Road, Rochester

2/5CMS overallStaff 2·Health 3
$9K in fines · 1 fine

Nursing home · 40 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Latta Road Nursing Home West

2100 Latta Road, Rochester

5/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 5

Nursing home · 40 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

The Brightonian, Inc

1919 Elmwood Avenue, Rochester

5/5CMS overallStaff 2·Health 5

Nursing home · 54 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

The Hurlbut

1177 East Henrietta Road, Rochester

3/5CMS overallStaff 2·Health 3

Nursing home · 160 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Waterview Heights Rehabilitation And Nursing Cente

135 Meridan St., Rochester

Special Focus Facility$805K in fines · 3 fines

Nursing home · 229 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Woodside Manor Nursing Home Inc

2425 Clinton Avenue South, Rochester

4/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 4

Nursing home · 44 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Seneca Nursing & Rehabilitation Center, Llc

200 Douglas Drive, Waterloo

4/5CMS overallStaff 2·Health 4

Nursing home · 120 certified beds · For-profit

Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026

Source: CMS Nursing Home Chain Performance Measures (chain-wide rollups), as of June 2026 · CMS SNF Enrollments + CMS Care Compare provider information (per-facility records).