Otterbein Franklin Seniorlife Comm Res & Com Care
1070 W Jefferson St, Franklin
2/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 2
Nursing home · 208 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Federal record · CMS Chain Performance Measures · Snapshot JUN 8 2026
Nursing-home chain
Otterbein Seniorlife
We list 19 facilities in Indiana and Ohio, with CMS Care Compare ratings, ownership disclosures, and inspection histories on each.
Facilities listed
19
2 states
Chain-wide footprint
19
2 states (CMS-wide)
Avg overall rating
2.9 / 5
CMS chain-wide
Total fines
$121,501
6 fines
5% for-profit90% non-profit5% government-owned
Facilities by state
Indiana
1 facility in Indiana
Ohio
18 facilities in Ohio
Otterbein Union Township
1114 Neighborhood Drive, Batavia
3/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 3
$7K in fines · 1 fine
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Springboro
9320 Avalon Circle, Centerville
5/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 4
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein-Cridersville
100 Red Oak Drive, Cridersville
3/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 3
Nursing home · 50 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Middletown
105 Atrium Drive, Franklin
4/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 3
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Gahanna
402 Liberty Way, Gahanna
2/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 1
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein At Granville
2158 Columbus Road, Granville
5/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 5
Nursing home · 22 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein North Shore
9400 North Shore Blvd, Lakeside
3/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 3
Nursing home · 20 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Lebanon Retirement Community
585 North State Route 741, Lebanon
5/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 4
Nursing home · 154 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Loveland
6405 Small House Circle, Loveland
1/5CMS overallStaff 1·Health 2
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein At Maineville
201 Marge Schott Way, Maineville
3/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 3
$44K in fines · 3 fines
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Monclova
5069 Otterbein Way, Monclova
1/5CMS overallStaff 1·Health 2
$47K in fines · 1 fine
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Government
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein New Albany
6690 Liberation Way, New Albany
2/5CMS overallStaff 1·Health 2
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Portage Valley
20311 Pemberville Rd, Pemberville
4/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 3
Nursing home · 50 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Avalon By Otterbein At Perrysburg
3525 - 3533 Rivers Edge Drive, Perrysburg
3/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 3
Nursing home · 60 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community
11230 State Route 364, St Marys
4/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 4
Nursing home · 53 certified beds · For-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Sunset Village
9640 Sylvania-Metamora Road, Sylvania
2/5CMS overallStaff 4·Health 2
Nursing home · 50 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Otterbein Sunset House
4020 Indian Rd, Toledo
3/5CMS overallStaff 3·Health 3
Nursing home · 24 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Green Hills Center
6557 Us 68 South, West Liberty
4/5CMS overallStaff 2·Health 3
$17K in fines · 1 fine
Nursing home · 74 certified beds · Non-profit
Verified·CMS Care Compare Jun 2026
Source: CMS Nursing Home Chain Performance Measures (chain-wide rollups), as of June 2026 · CMS SNF Enrollments + CMS Care Compare provider information (per-facility records).